Recently, there has been heated discussion about the NGO group Collective Shout causing some Steam and itch.io games to be removed from the store. However, the perspective is mainly on the victims such as game developers, so it is necessary to look at CS’s own statement on this matter.
This incident originated from CS’s request to remove No Mercy because CS believes that the game uses descriptions of rape and incestuous pornography as entertainment, which promotes the objectification of women and sexual violence. Steam does not have reliable age verification to ensure that minors are not exposed to it. Therefore, they first sent an email to Steam, but Steam ignored these emails. Two months after the incident, CS began sending emails to payment processors to exert pressure.
It seems that CS’s behavior is still somewhat polite. However, No Mercy was removed from the store shortly after the incident. Steam’s silence on the matter seems to have angered CS, so CS supporters began demanding that Gabe Newell delete all rape/incest games.
CS’s idea is of course absurd, because age restrictions can never be perfectly implemented (even in the People’s Republic of China), so CS will always have a reason to demand the removal of content that is not suitable for minors. The question of whether works with criminal themes will lead to crime is merely CS’s value judgment. Even if all films, novels, and games with criminal themes are banned, it should not have a positive impact on the crime rate.
So, what CS has done is just self-satisfaction. The originally niche No Mercy game has become well-known because of CS’s noise, and there are related resources available for download on various pirated websites. And when legal fictional works that do not harm anyone disappear, will those who are interested in this type of subject matter go to the dark web? Using cryptocurrency that CS cannot monitor by email to “support” real criminal content that harms people…
P.S.: The first editorial on the homepage of CS’s official website is “Ban Porn on X”, and the banner below introduces its achievements, including removing billboards that promote the objectification of women, removing sexy children’s clothing (hot pants, slightly hollowed-out tops, clothing with chest pads), removing sexually violent games, etc. The founder, Melinda Tankard Reist, is an anti-abortion feminist and anti-pornography activist.